Big Garden Birdwatch: How Do We Compare?

The RSPB has published the results of its national Bird Garden Birdwatch survey, held over the weekend of 28/29 January 2012. We held our own "big garden" survey on Hilly Fields on 29 January and a total of 23 species was identified by all who took part. It is interesting to compare the top 23 birds in the national survey with our list:

  Hilly Fields Survey                                National Survey

  1. Starling                                                    1. House Sparrow

  2. House Sparrow                                      2. Starling

  3. Black-headed Gull                                 3. Blue Tit

4. Common Gull 4. Blackbird

5. Goldfinch 5. Chaffinch

  6. Ring-necked Parakeet                          6. Woodpigeon

  7. Blackbird                                                 7. Goldfinch 

  8. Woodpigeon                                            8. Great Tit

  9. Blue Tit                                                   9. Robin

  9. Greenfinch                                             10. Collared Dove     

  9. Magpie                                                   11. Dunnock

 10. Carrion Crow                                       12. Magpie

 10. Chaffinch                                              13. Long-tailed Tit 

 10. Feral Pigeon                                        14. Greenfinch

 10. Great Tit                                              15. Feral Pigeon

 10. Jay                                                        16. Coal Tit

 10. Long-tailed Tit                                    17. Jackdaw

 10. Robin                                                    18. Carrion Crow

 11. Mistle Thrush                                      19. Wren

 11. Wren                                                     20. Common Gull

 12. Dunnock                                               21. Pheasant 

 12. Great Spotted Woodpecker               22. Song Thrush

 12. Pied Wagtail                                         23. Bullfinch 

There is a 73% match between the two lists, so - as you might expect - Hilly Fields does not differ enormously as a bird habitat from gardens and parks across the UK. Our list is skewed slightly by the winter timing of the survey when there are flocks of gulls on Hilly Fields and the Starling population is at its height. There also seems to have been a larger number of House Sparrows on HF that day than usual (16 were counted - the norm is between 4 and 8).

The six birds which are on our list but not in the national Top 23 are: Black-headed Gull (a very common winter bird in London), Great Spotted Woodpecker (no. 24 on the national list!), Jay, Mistle Thrush, Pied Wagtail and Ring-necked Parakeet. The pesky Parakeet is still predominantly a Southern England bird and, in London, most common south of the river.

The six birds which are in the national Top 23 but not on our list are: Bullfinch, Coal Tit, Collared Dove, Jackdaw, Pheasant and Song Thrush. These can all be seen in the London area with varying degrees of frequency. Locally, Song Thrushes can be seen/heard in Brockley Cemetery and Brookmill Park, Jackdaws in Greenwich Park (when not closed for the Olympics) and I've seen a Collared Dove on top of a bus shelter in Hilly Fields Crescent but forgot to record the date!

The national RSPB survey has drawn attention to the 79% decline in Starling numbers recorded since the Big Garden Birdwatch began in 1979. In fact, both the House Sparrow and the Starling - despite still being the two most recorded birds in our gardens and parks - have declined so much numerically that they are now on the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species. Hopefully, both populations will at least stabilize.